NPR for North Texas
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

James Broadnax is scheduled to die for Garland murders. Now his cousin claims he shot the victims

A gurney with restraints sits in an empty room with green walls and a two-way mirror.
Pat Sullivan
/
AP File Photo
James Broadnax is facing an April 30 execution date for the fatal shootings of two Christian music producers in Garland in 2008. His cousin has now confessed to shooting the men.

Just six weeks before James Broadnax faces execution for the 2008 fatal shooting of two Christian music producers in Garland, his cousin has claimed he killed them.

Broadnax, now 37, was convicted in Dallas County in 2009 for robbing, shooting and killing Stephen Swan and Matthew Butler.
He is scheduled to be executed by lethal injection on April 30.

His cousin, Demarius Cummings, has confessed in a sworn statement that he pulled the trigger.

Cummings's statement claims that he and Broadnax agreed to tell the story that Broadnax was the shooter because he did not have a prior criminal record. Cummings did.

Both convicted men would remain eligible for a capital murder charge. A sentence of death life or life in prison are the only options.

Broadnax's lawyers said they would likely fight the "law of parties" rule that makes anyone associated with the same crime subject to the same charges.

Lawyers for Broadnax are asking the Dallas County District Attorney's office to vacate the execution date, and for the state court of appeals to pause the date.

The legal team, led by Steven Herzog, filed Supreme Court appeals within the last month hoping to temporarily stop the execution and have time to more carefully review evidence and procedures from the trial, said media representative Allen Ripp of New York.

The Supreme Court appeal filing says characterizing Broadnax's lyrics as "gangster rap" was racially biased.

They say his civil rights were violated during trial because Black jurors were excluded from serving.

Then, at age 19, Broadnax told KXAS-TV, NBC in an interview from jail that he was ready to face any justice.

Got a tip? Email Marina Trahan Martinez at mmartinez@kera.org. You can follow Marina at @HisGirlHildy.

KERA News is made possible through the generosity of our members. If you find this reporting valuable, consider making a tax-deductible gift today. Thank you.

Marina Trahan Martinez is KERA's Dallas County government accountability reporter. She's a veteran journalist who has worked in the Dallas area for many years. Prior to coming to KERA, she was on The Dallas Morning News Watchdog investigative and accountability team with Dave Lieber. She has written for The New York Times since 2001, following the 9/11 attacks. Many of her stories for The Times focused on social justice and law enforcement, including Botham Jean's murder by a Dallas police officer and her subsequent trial, Atatiana Jefferson's shooting death by a Fort Worth police officer, and protests following George Floyd's murder. Marina was part of The News team that a Pulitzer finalist for coverage of the deadly ambush of Dallas police officers in 2016.